Find out the value of a Vinyl Record, CD, or Cassette, etc. Search within our Price Guide of Sold Auctions
Vinyl: Johnny Mathis, 11 Vinyl Record Lot, 8 LP, 2 DLP & 1 7”, 10 US 1st 2 Sealed 1 Red

Johnny Mathis
11 Vinyl Record Lot
8 LP’s, 2 Double LP’s & 1 7” Single
10 US 1st Pressing, including 2 Mint, Sealed, 1 White Label Promo Copy with Red Vinyl
Records listed below in chronological order of original release date.
Johnny Mathis
Wonderful! Wonderful! Vinyl LP
Columbia Records, CL 1028, Mono, 1957
US 1st Pressing; Six-eye Label
Vinyl is in NEAR MINT condition, with no scuffs or needle marks.
Cover is in VERY GOOD++ condition, with small stain on bottom right corner.
Columbia stock record sleeve.
Side One: Will I Find My Love Today, Looking At You, Let Me Love You, All Through The Night, It Could Happen To You, That Old Black Magic
Side Two: Too Close For Comfort, In The Wee Small Hours Of The Morning, Year After Year, Early Autumn, You Stepped Out Of A Dream, Day In Day Out
Johnny Mathis
Merry Christmas Vinyl LP, Mint, Sealed
Columbia Records, CS 8021, Stereo, 1959
US 1st Pressing
Vinyl is in MINT, SEALED condition.
Cover is in VERY GOOD++ condition, still sealed in original shrink with very small tear in shrink and stain on bottom right corner.
Side One: Winter Wonderland, The Christmas Song, Sleigh Ride, Blue Christmas, I'll Be Home For Christmas, White Christmas
Side Two: O Holy Night, What Child Is This? (Greensleeves), The First Noel, Silver Bells, It Came Upon A Midnight Clear, Silent Night, Holy Night
Johnny Mathis
Open Fire, Two Guitars Vinyl LP
Columbia Records, CL 1270, Mono, 1959
US 1st Pressing; Six-eye Label
Vinyl is in NEAR MINT condition, with no scuffs or needle marks.
Cover is in VERY GOOD+ condition, with very light ring wear and name written on back cover (small).
Columbia stock record sleeve.
Side One: An Open Fire, Bye Bye Blackbird, In The Still Of The Night, Embraceable You, I'll Be Seeing You. Tenderly
Side Two: When I Fall In Love, I Concentrate On You, Please Be Kind, You'll Never Know, I'm Just A Boy In Love, My Funny Valentine
Johnny Mathis
The Rhythms And Ballads Of Broadway Vinyl Double LP
Columbia Records, C2S 803, Stereo, 1960
US 1st Pressing; Six-eye Label
Both records are in VERY GOOD++ condition, with very few light sleeve scuffs and needle marks.
Laminated Gatefold Cover is in NEAR MINT- condition, with minimal ring wear.
Columbia stock record sleeves.
The Ballads Of Broadway
Side One: Moanin' Low, Fun To Be Fooled, I Have Dreamed, On The Sunny Side Of The Street, My Romance, Dancing On The Ceiling
Side Two: I Married An Angel, Isn't It A Pity, Spring Is Here, Don't Blame Me, Taking A Chance On Love, The Party's Over
The Rhythms Of Broadway
Side Three: Everything's Coming Up Roses, Guys And Dolls, I Wish I Were In Love Again, You Do Something To Me, Let's Misbehave, I Could Have Danced All Night
Side Four: A Cock-Eyed Optimist, I Just Found Out About Love, Let's Do It, I Am In Love, Love Eyes, Love Is A Gamble
Johnny Mathis
What Will Mary Say Vinyl 7” 45 RPM Single, White Label Promo Copy, Red Vinyl
Columbia Records, 4-42666, Stereo, Jan 1963
US 1st Pressing; “Not For Sale, Radio Station Copy” printed on white labels
Vinyl is in VERY GOOD++ condition, with very few light sleeve scuffs and needle marks.
Clear plastic record sleeve.
Both Sides: What Will My Mary Say 3:10
Johnny Mathis
Romantically Vinyl LP
Columbia Records, CS 8898, Stereo, Nov 1963
US 1st Pressing
Vinyl is in VERY GOOD++ condition, with very few light sleeve scuffs and needle marks.
Cover is in VERY GOOD++ condition, with very light ring wear.
Clear vinyl record sleeve.
Side One: Getting To Know You (From "The King And I") 3:11, Moonlight In Vermont 3:40, Hi-Lili, Hi-Lo 3:30, Friendly Persuasion (Thee I Love) 3:51, Autumn In New York 4:50, In Wisconsin 3:15
Side Two: All That Is Missing 2:58, The Sound Of Music (From "The Sound Of Music ") 3:22, Theme From "Carnival" 2:33, Too Young To Go Steady 3:42, It's Only A Paper Moon 3:53, September Song 4:07
Johnny Mathis
Johnny Vinyl LP
Columbia Limited Edition, LE 10785, Stereo, 1963
US Reissue, 1970.
Vinyl is in NEAR MINT condition, with no scuffs or needle marks.
Cover is in NEAR MINT condition, still in original shrink.
Plain white record sleeve.
Side One: Easy Does It 2:08, The Most Beautiful Girl In The World 3:45, Miracles 2:50, When The World Was Young 3:48, Never Never Land 4:00, Poor Butterfly 4:15
Side Two: Jump For Joy 2:05, Joey, Joey, Joey 3:57, I Can't Believe That You're In Love With Me 3:00, I Love You 3:28, Weaver Of Dreams 3:14, No Man Can Stand Alone 2:35
Johnny Mathis
I Just Found Out About Love! Vinyl LP, Compilation
Columbia Musical Treasuries, DS 446, Stereo, 1969
US 1st Pressing
Vinyl is in NEAR MINT condition, with no scuffs or needle marks.
Cover is in VERY GOOD++ condition, with very light ring wear.
Plain white record sleeve.
Side One: A Lovely Way To Spend An Evening, I'm In The Mood For Love, I Just Found Out About Love And I Like It, Can't Get Out Of This Mood, Don't Blame Me
Side Two: Warm And Willing, When My Sugar Walks Down The Street, Love Me As Though There Were No Tomorrow, Where Are You?, Too Young To Go Steady, On The Sunny Side Of The Street
Johnny Mathis
Johnny Mathis' All-Time Greatest Hits Vinyl Double LP, Compilation
Columbia Records, PG 31345, Stereo, 1972
US 1st Pressing
Both records are in NEAR MINT condition, with no scuffs or needle marks.
Top-loading Gatefold Cover is in VERY GOOD++ condition, with very light ring wear.
Plain white record sleeves.
Side One: A Certain Smile 2:47, When Sunny Gets Blue 2:41, Small World 3:18, Misty 3:34, Chances Are 3:03
Side Two: Venus 2:36, Maria 3:45, Misty Roses 2:39, Gina 2:46, What Will My Mary Say 3:09
Side Three: (Where Do I Begin) Love Story 2:46, If We Only Have Love 3:16, My Funny Valentine 3:33, Come To Me 3:05, Love Theme From "Romeo And Juliet" 2:58
Side Four: Wonderful! Wonderful! 2:50, All The Time 2:44, The Twelfth Of Never 2:28, Wild Is The Wind 2:26, It's Not For Me To Say 3:05
Johnny Mathis
Friends In Love Vinyl LP
Columbia Records, FC 37748, Stereo, 1982
US 1st Pressing
Vinyl is in NEAR MINT condition, with no scuffs or needle marks.
Cover is in VERY GOOD++ condition, with very small stain on bottom right corner.
Plain white record sleeve.
Side One: Got You Where I Want You 3:43, I Remember You And Me 3:46, When The Lovin' Goes Out Of The Lovin' 4:19, Somethin's Goin' On 3:21, What Do You Do With The Love 3:28
Side Two: Friends In Love 4:03, What's Forever For 3:22, Warm 4:39, Memory (Theme From Cats) 3:00, Lately 4:05
Johnny Mathis, Henry Mancini
The Hollywood Musicals Vinyl LP, Mint, Sealed
Columbia Records, FC 40372, Stereo, 1986
US 1st Pressing
Vinyl is in MINT, SEALED condition.
Cover is in VERY GOOD++ condition, still sealed in original shrink with very small tear in shrink and stain on bottom right corner.
Side One: You Stepped Out Of A Dream 3:30, Taking A Chance On Love 3:00, When You Wish Upon A Star 3:40, True Love 3:06, Whistling Away The Dark 3:19, Time After Time 3:27
Side Two: It Might As Well Be Spring 4:34, I Had The Craziest Dream 3:05, Long Ago (And Far Away) 4:00, Crazy World 3:21, Johnny Burke/Jimmy Van Heusen Medley (7:05) - 5a Moonlight Becomes You, 5b It Could Happen To You, 5c But Beautiful
Please See My Other Listings For More Great Vinyl!
Worldwide shipping costs calculated above. Please contact if you have any shipping questions.
I will combine shipping for multiple purchases.
PayPal accepted. Payment expected within 3 days. Please ask before bidding if more time is needed.